Options Trading Podcast
The go-to podcast for options traders who want clarity, consistency, and control in their trading journey. Built on the trusted educational foundation of OptionGenius.com, this show delivers straightforward, no-fluff insights to help you master the world of options trading.
Options Trading Podcast
What are intrinsic value and extrinsic (time) value in an option?
Have you ever wondered what you're actually paying for when you buy an options contract? In this deep dive, we break down the fundamental parts of an option's price: intrinsic value (the "meat") and extrinsic value (the "hope"). We use simple analogies and real examples to help you move from guessing to truly understanding why options lose value and how sellers use this to their advantage. We also mention some resources like Option Picks, the Options Traders Alliance, and the term theta.
Where else in your financial life are you paying for hope instead of focusing on verifiable value? Let us know and be sure to subscribe for more simple options trading guidance.
Key Takeaways
- An option’s price is always the sum of its intrinsic value plus its extrinsic value.
- Intrinsic value is the "real" value an option has if it were exercised right now. It's the amount an option is "in the money" and can't be negative.
- Extrinsic value is the rest of the option's price, representing the market's expectation for a favorable move before expiration. It's driven by time and implied volatility.
- Time decay, measured by theta, is a key factor. Extrinsic value melts away every day, accelerating as the expiration date gets closer. This works against buyers and in favor of sellers.
- Sellers profit from collecting the extrinsic value (hope) upfront, while buyers pay for it, hoping for a big enough price swing to turn that hope into intrinsic value.
"When you sell an option, you're essentially selling hope, you're selling time, you're selling emotion... and what do you get immediately in return? The premium."
Timestamped Summary
- 0:50 The core mission: Breaking down intrinsic vs. extrinsic value
- 2:32 What is intrinsic value? The "meat" of the sandwich
- 4:38 What is extrinsic value? The "hope" or "fuzzier part"
- 7:18 The silent killer for buyers: Time decay
- 9:00 The seller's perspective: Collecting premium
- 15:00 Thinking more like the "house" by understanding the mechanics
Subscribe to the podcast so you don't miss our next deep dive into options trading basics!
Welcome to the Options Trading Podcast. We're on a mission to empower individual investors with the knowledge they need. Join us as we break down complex topics into simple, step-by-step guidance for conservative options trading.
Speaker 2:Options trading. It's this area that pulls a lot of people in, you know, with this idea of making big money fast. But if you've ever actually tried it, or maybe just watched, you probably know that for most people it feels less like a smart strategy and more like buying a lottery ticket, and often the money just kind of vanishes.
Speaker 3:It's a really common pattern and, honestly, a lot of it just boils down to not getting the basic pieces of an options price. People see that price tag but they don't really grasp what's bundled up inside.
Speaker 2:Right, it's like buying some complex gadget just based on the sticker price without knowing what the individual parts actually cost. So, ok, our mission in this deep dive we've got this stack of sources you brought is to really break down those two fundamental parts intrinsic value versus extrinsic value. We want to help you, the listener, look at an option price and actually know what you're paying for. You know, move from just guessing to really understanding.
Speaker 3:And before we really unpack those two values, maybe let's just quickly touch on the absolute basics from the material. So, an option, it's a contract. It gives the buyer the right. An option it's a contract, okay, it gives the buyer the right, but and this is key, not the obligation, to either buy that's a call option or sell that's a put option. Some asset? Like a stock Right At a specific price that's the strike price, and it has to be done on or before a certain date, the expiration date.
Speaker 2:Okay, right, not the obligation Trade at a set price by a deadline. Seems simple enough, but the sources really hammer home this key formula for the price you pay for that right.
Speaker 3:Absolutely, it's foundational. The equation is always option. Price equals intrinsic value plus extrinsic value. Every single penny of that price falls into one of those two buckets.
Speaker 2:And the sources had a pretty good analogy for this, didn't they Something about a sandwich?
Speaker 3:Yeah, it helps visualize it. Think of intrinsic value as the meat in the sandwich. It's the solid bit, the part that has real substance right now. Okay, the meat, extrinsic value, that's well everything else the bun, the lettuce, mayo, whatever all the other stuff that adds to it or adds potential, but isn't the core value itself.
Speaker 2:So it sounds like a lot of people might be paying quite a bit for the bun, kind of hoping there's some meat inside. Let's start with the meat, then Intrinsic value.
Speaker 3:Right, so intrinsic value is the part of an options price that is already in the money. In the money, meaning? Meaning like if you could snap your fingers and exercise that option right now, this very second, would it actually be worth something? Would you make money, just based on the current market price?
Speaker 2:Okay, Walk us through the example. They used the Apple one.
Speaker 3:Sure. So imagine Apple stock is trading right now at $180 per share and you own a call option that gives you the right to buy Apple at $170.
Speaker 2:Okay, so my contract says I can buy $170, but the market says it's worth $180 right now.
Speaker 3:Exactly so that $10 difference per share, the $180 market price minus your $170 strike price, that is the intrinsic value. It's real, it's immediate, it's the meat you get if you exercise right away.
Speaker 2:Got it. Yeah, that's like actual value I'd have if I acted now. Okay, but what if Apple was down, say, trading at $160, and I still had that same $170 call option?
Speaker 3:Ah, good question. In that situation, your right to buy at $170 is well, it's higher than the current market price of $160.
Speaker 2:So exercising would mean paying more than it's worth.
Speaker 3:Precisely. You'd be buying at $170 something you could immediately sell for only $160. That's a loss, so the option is out of the money, right, and in that case its intrinsic value is zero Zilch. There's no immediate profit baked in from exercising. Like the source material says no meat, just soggy bread.
Speaker 2:Okay, so you can't have negative intrinsic value. Then it's either positive or it bottoms out at zero.
Speaker 3:Exactly right. That's a super important point. The math works like this For calls intrinsic value is stock price minus strike price, but only if that's positive. If the stock price is below the strike or equal, intrinsic value is zero. And for puts the right to sell it's flipped Strike price minus stock price, Again, only if that's positive, Otherwise it's zero All right.
Speaker 2:Intrinsic value is a real, verifiable, right now profit potential. Got it? Let's tackle the other side. Extrinsic value. This feels, I don't know, maybe the fuzzier part, the trickier one.
Speaker 3:It definitely can be. Extrinsic value is basically everything else in that options price. That isn't intrinsic value. It's the component that's based on the what if?
Speaker 2:The what if like. What if the stock moves?
Speaker 3:Exactly. It represents the market's expectation, or maybe just hope, that the stock price will move favorably before that option expires, and our sources say it's driven primarily by two big things how much time is left until expiration?
Speaker 2:OK.
Speaker 3:And the expected volatility of the stock, how much people think it's likely to jump around?
Speaker 2:Time and potential movement OK.
Speaker 3:So the more time you have left generally, the greater the chance for some big price swing Right. So options with like months to go usually have more extrinsic value built in than options expiring next week. You're paying for more days of possibility.
Speaker 2:But that possibility, that hope factor, yeah. It doesn't last forever, does it? Yeah. This is where that time decay thing comes in.
Speaker 3:Bingo. Yeah, this is the silent killer for a lot of option buyers. Every single day that ticks by, a little bit of that extrinsic value just evaporates, decays. Why? Because there's simply less time remaining for that hoped for big move to actually happen. The possibility you paid for is shrinking day by day.
Speaker 2:OK, let's, let's go back to that Apple example to make this concrete.
Speaker 3:OK, so Apple's still trading at one hundred and eighty dollars. You've got that one hundred and seventy dollar strike call option and let's say there are 30 days left until it expires. The sources suggest maybe the total price for that option is, say, $12.
Speaker 2:Okay, and we already figured out that $10 of that, $12 is the intrinsic value, the real stuff.
Speaker 3:Right, so the remaining $2, that difference, that is the extrinsic value, that $2 represents the time value, the market premium for those 30 days of potential that Apple might go even higher.
Speaker 2:And if the next day Apple is still $180, hasn't moved, but now there are only 29 days left.
Speaker 3:Well, that options price will likely have dropped a little bit, maybe to $11.
Speaker 2:Even though the stock didn't change.
Speaker 3:Even though the stock didn't change that 20 cents didn't disappear because of Apple's price. It vanished purely because of time decay, eating away at that initial $2 of extrinsic value. If you're the buyer, the clock is ticking against you Wow.
Speaker 1:Have you ever wondered how professional traders pick their next option trade? Here's the secret they use trusted signals from services like OptionPix. It's totally free Just enter your email and wake up each morning with the top option trades, vetted by pros. No guesswork, no stress, just actionable trades. To help you enter the market smartly, head over to weloveoptionscom. Slash option picks and grab your free daily trades. Try it. You might love how much time you save.
Speaker 2:Okay. So if absolutely nothing changes with Apple's stock price day after day by the time expiration day actually arrives, that option will only be worth its intrinsic value, which is still $10 in this case, exactly that whole $2 of extrinsic value you paid up front will have completely melted away to zero.
Speaker 3:Precisely, and this is really where extrinsic value can kind of trick people, especially new traders. They end up paying mostly for that hope, that potential future move, not realizing how quickly it disappears.
Speaker 2:And I bet this is even more stark with options that start out of the money right, the ones with zero intrinsic value to begin with.
Speaker 3:Oh, absolutely. The sources use a great example for this. Imagine a stock is trading at $50 and you decide okay, I think it's going up, so you buy a call option with a $60 strike price and maybe you pay $1 for that option.
Speaker 2:Okay, a $60 strike when the stock's only at $50, that means zero intrinsic value, right? No meat at all, correct?
Speaker 3:Zero. So every single penny of that $1 premium you paid it is pure, 100%, extrinsic value. You are literally paying a dollar just for the chance, the possibility that the stock price doesn't just get to $60, but actually goes above $61 before expiration, just for you to break even on the trade.
Speaker 2:And if that big jump doesn't happen, that dollar is just gone, melting away every day because of decay. The sources really stress how this might seem like a small loss on one trade, but it adds up fast, yeah. Or it can be a big loss if the option was more expensive. It's how money gets lost, slowly and quietly.
Speaker 3:Yeah, it's the cost of admission for a potential future that might just never show up.
Speaker 2:OK, now this next bit from the sources. This is where the perspective really shifts. It's fascinating. They start talking about being the seller of the option.
Speaker 3:Right, and this is where understanding intrinsic versus extrinsic is just incredibly powerful, because, while most people are drawn to buying options, hoping for that home run the person on the other side of that trade, the seller they're playing a completely different game.
Speaker 2:How so.
Speaker 3:Well, they are the ones who collect that extrinsic value premium upfront.
Speaker 2:Wait, they're selling the hope the buyer is paying for.
Speaker 3:That's a perfect way to put it. The material describes it really vividly. When you sell an option, you're essentially selling hope, you're selling time, you're selling emotion, maybe fear or greed, and what do you get immediately in return?
Speaker 2:The premium.
Speaker 3:Cold hard cash instantly credited to your account.
Speaker 2:OK, so if the stock doesn't make that big move the buyer was hoping for, that extrinsic value just evaporates over time, like we said.
Speaker 3:And where does it evaporate to? It disappears from the options price, but it effectively stays in the seller's pocket. That premium they collected becomes their profit. Yeah, one source uses the analogy of selling ice cubes in the desert. As a seller, you kind of know that time decay is going to meld away that hope value. Time is actively working for you because that extrinsic premium you pocketed is destined to shrink towards zero if the option doesn't go deep in the money.
Speaker 2:That really does flip the whole thing on its head. You go from fighting against time decay to actually benefiting from it.
Speaker 3:And getting that fundamental difference immediately shines a light on the common traps that so many new options traders fall into. The sources are really clear about these pitfalls.
Speaker 2:Okay, what are the big ones, the main mistakes people make.
Speaker 3:Well, number one is just ignoring this whole distinction. We've been talking about Ignoring intrinsic versus extrinsic. They just see a price, buy it and don't realize they might be paying a massive premium just for hope, you know, with very little actual tangible value underneath.
Speaker 2:This probably leads right into the next one. Yeah, Chasing those super cheap way out of the money options.
Speaker 3:Absolutely. The sources call them what they are lottery tickets. They look cheap, maybe only a few cents, but because they have zero intrinsic value, their entire price is extrinsic value.
Speaker 2:Which decays really fast.
Speaker 3:Super fast and they're basically designed statistically to expire worthless unless you get a huge unlikely move in the stock price very quickly. You need a massive win just to break even sometimes.
Speaker 2:Okay, Another mistake they mentioned holding on too long, holding right until expiration.
Speaker 3:Yeah, this ties directly back to how time decay works. It's not a straight line down. It actually accelerates the closer you get to the expiration date.
Speaker 2:Oh right, Like the decay speeds up near the end.
Speaker 3:Exactly. The loss of extrinsic value per day gets faster and faster in those final weeks or days. So holding on as a buyer until the very end means you're exposing yourself to the most rapid decay.
Speaker 2:Like the analogy they used waiting to pull the parachute cord until you're only 100 feet from the ground.
Speaker 3:Pretty much Not a good strategy for the buyer. For the seller, though, that accelerating decay is expiration years. That's exactly what they want to see.
Speaker 2:And the last big mistake was just not getting that the decay is exponential not just a steady trickle.
Speaker 3:Yeah, understanding that acceleration is key. That extrinsic value doesn't just politely decline. It falls off a cliff towards the end. Buyers need to grasp that because it tells them when that hope value they paid for is going to vanish most rapidly.
Speaker 2:Okay. So, knowing all this, understanding these two parts of the price and how decay works, what are the practical, actionable tips the sources give us?
Speaker 3:All right. So, based on this core understanding, the advice is pretty clear. If you are buying options, especially calls, the sources generally recommend focusing on options that are already in the money. Why? Because a larger portion of the price you pay will be for that solid intrinsic value, the meat You're spending less on the purely speculative extrinsic value that's going to decay away.
Speaker 2:Pay for the meat, not just the bun and the hope sauce. Exactly.
Speaker 1:Think you need eight screens, five hours a day and a Wall Street background to trade options? Think again. The Options Traders Alliance is a free Facebook group where real people are building real income with simplified options strategies, including covered calls, naked puts, credit spreads, condors, butterflies and more high probability setups. You'll get tips, tools and coaching from pros who actually trade what they teach. Join now at weloveoptionscom slash free group and start trading smarter with people who've got your back.
Speaker 3:Now, conversely, if you are selling options, the strategy flips. You'd often target those out-of-the-money options, particularly ones that still have a decent amount of extrinsic value packed into their price.
Speaker 2:Because that's the part you collect and hope decays.
Speaker 3:That's where the juice is, as one source puts it. That's the premium you pocket, and if the stop doesn't make a huge move against you, time decay works in your favor to erode that value.
Speaker 2:And obviously keeping a close eye on the calendar is crucial either way.
Speaker 3:Oh, absolutely vital. Time is probably the biggest factor besides the stock price itself. It's constantly working against the buyer, constantly helping the seller. Assuming the price stays stable, you absolutely have to manage your trades based on how much time is left.
Speaker 2:And the sources brought up a specific term for measuring this decay theta.
Speaker 3:Yeah, theta. It's one of the Greeks, which are just metrics used to measure different risks and characteristics of options. Theta specifically tells you how much extrinsic value an option is expected to lose per day just due to the passage of time.
Speaker 2:So buyers don't want high theta.
Speaker 3:Generally no. High theta means the option's time value is decaying quickly. Sellers, on the other hand, often look for high theta situations because they profit from that rapid decay quickly. Sellers, on the other hand, often look for high theta situations because they profit from that rapid decay.
Speaker 2:Huh, so understanding intrinsic versus extrinsic and how time decay like theta works, yeah, it's not just theory, it directly shapes your strategy.
Speaker 3:It fundamentally changes the game and moves you away from treating options like you know random bets on a roulette wheel and towards understanding the actual mechanics. The sources really nailed this point. Options aren't magic. They're based on math and quantifiable factors, and when you truly grasp intrinsic and extrinsic value, you stop being the person just kind of hoping for that long shot payout.
Speaker 3:And you can start thinking more like the house, as they put it, the one who aims to make money more consistently like a casino, small wins often predictably, primarily from capturing that decaying extrinsic value that others are willing to pay for.
Speaker 2:And our sources leave us, and you listening, with a really sharp set of questions to ask next time you even glance at an option price.
Speaker 3:Yeah, they urge you to stop and ask yourself first OK, how much of this price is real, tangible value right now? How much is intrinsic? And how much of this price is just hope? How much is just paying for time and possibility? How much is extrinsic?
Speaker 2:And then the big strategic question follows from that.
Speaker 3:And knowing that, do I want to be the buyer of that hope or do I want to be the seller of that hope? Grasping that difference, they argue, is the absolute key to making informed decisions instead of just gambling.
Speaker 2:And you know, if you take that core idea that part of the price of something can be purely based on time and the possibility of future events, that hope value versus the real value, how does that change how you might look at any potential investment, not just options? Where else in your financial life, or maybe even other areas, are you potentially paying for hope instead of focusing on the underlying verifiable value? It's a pretty interesting lens to carry around. This is an AI podcast based on educational material from Option Genius. Visit us today at optiongeniuscom.